Amsterdam, NY

Amsterdam, NY real estate market: appreciation, rent growth, cap rate, IRR, and property taxes.

Appreciation

: 3.8%/yr.

Rent growth

: 2.9%/yr.

Median cap rate

: 2.3%.

Median IRR

: 1.8%.

Median rental home value

: $145,200.

Median rental rate

: $940/mo.

Median property tax

: $3,872/yr.

Sources: FHFA House Price Index®, U.S. Census Bureau ACS 5-year estimates, and Rescover analysis of public single-family listings, updated September 2026.

Browse analyzed properties in Amsterdam, NY →

Top listings right now

111 W MAIN ST, CANAJOHARIE, NY 13317 $127,600· 3 bd· 2 ba
24 WAGNER ST, FORT PLAIN, NY 13339 $125,000· 3 bd· 1.5 ba
36 BROAD ST, AMSTERDAM, NY 12010 $159,000· 2 bd· 1.5 ba
81 FT JOHNSON AVE, FORT JOHNSON, NY 12070 $151,000· 3 bd· 1.5 ba
43 JAY ST, AMSTERDAM, NY 12010 $170,000· 5 bd· 1.5 ba
72 CENTER ST, FORT PLAIN, NY 13339 $142,000· 3 bd· 1 ba
17 Harrison Ave, Amsterdam, NY $169,000· 3 bd· 2 ba
15 Harrison Ave, Amsterdam, NY $169,000· 3 bd· 2 ba
105 Hartman Rd, Pattersonville, NY $159,900· 5 bd· 4 ba
19 Harrison Ave, Amsterdam, NY $183,500· 4 bd· 3 ba
45 CATHERINE ST, AMSTERDAM, NY 12010 $199,900· 3 bd· 1 ba
112 REID ST, FORT PLAIN, NY 13339 $170,000· 4 bd· 1.5 ba
134 S PAWLING ST, HAGAMAN, NY 12086 $215,000· 3 bd· 1 ba
6764 STATE HIGHWAY 10, CANAJOHARIE, NY 13317 $239,000· 3 bd· 1 ba
49 HASKELL ST, HAGAMAN, NY 12086 $245,000· 2 bd· 1 ba
236 HOLLOW RD, AMSTERDAM, NY 12010 $249,000· 3 bd· 2 ba
176 MILL LN, FORT PLAIN, NY 13339 $259,900· 4 bd· 2 ba
631 LATIMER HILL RD, CANAJOHARIE, NY 13317 $305,000· 4 bd· 3.5 ba
147 S PAWLING ST, HAGAMAN, NY 12086 $325,000· 2 bd· 1 ba

ZIP codes in Amsterdam, NY

Rental market data for every ZIP code in this micro area.